letter from a daughter of china
hi james,
how are you? i am glad you ask me about tibet. some people even don't do any research but they already made their mind by media.
have you heard cnn apologize for the fake picture and untrue report about tibet at the beginning of riot? of course not, they didn't repeat it as usual. but at least they did once and they took down the picture from internet as request. and in japan anybody who join to march for support tibet against olympic will be paid 100 euro per day, this is my friend who study in tokyo phoned me and told me, by the way there were 3000 chinese people on o'connell st to march for support olympic and chinese government, we informed all the tv channel, but nobody came on that day to report, only irish time took picture then report it in the middle of pages. but there were 3 tibet people with flag standing on street a few monthes ago, their news everywhere. i do understand we need fully respect 3 tibet people's voice, but why ignore our 3000 people's voice and stories? why fake news from cnn?why western media try to block all the support government news?what's going on?
One thing is for sure , we are not American following dog! at least we didn't vote yes on the issue of iraq war just for get bush's happy face! Honestly, we have completely opposite political system from western country. And we are getting stronger and stronger, but does that means we will control the world and cause the war?have you see any that type Chinese? i want to say we are easy going and hard working people. we don't want to cause any trouble, we just want to let our life getting better and better, under this government, our life getting much better, they still have problems, but they are progressing for the country, I grew up in china and stayed in Ireland for 7 years, and come back china once per year, I watch cnn bbc everyday in ireland. my eyes tell me the truth! not cnn or bbc. Tibet is a big tourist place not only for foreigner but also for Chinese, my father was there for holiday and his collegue was working there for 3 years. the people have peaceful and religion life there, government don't want change their life at all, maybe their special life style can attract a lot tourists as well. But the people there have right to choose their own life style, not just following the tradition. So the government build school, restaurants, electricity, tv, shower (because as tradition they only should have 3 showers in their life.). if they want to go to school for education instead of going to temple for all their life, they have right to choose themselves, not dalai lama!! nobody should use religion to control their people, people have right to choose their life and religion! do you think dalai lama would be happy to see his followers getting less and less? Do you think American like us to be stronger? Are they really care about our people's life or they just try to destroy our government to build another new one who can only say yes to American!?why they only report bad news about us?why they wouldn't let word know 99.9% chinese support and happy about our current government? Inside Tibet the people are very angery about the western media un truth reports, they are happy about their life but some people try to use riot monks to make up stories. that's why dalai lama state that he didn't seek independent but freedom, actually he knew nobody will vote for him except his following monks and American! because people are happy there, that's the real truth!
Even if we open the gate of tibet for western media, but they only report a few monks voice and ignore most Tibet people's voice, what should we do?
Can our true voice be heard by world? Can we spread truth bigger than cnn, bbc, wester media community? From this lesson, we know we can't. they are too strong. They can tell whatever they want , truth or fake, it is up to them. we were crying without sound when we see all the world try to against Chinese government which they are making effort to develop our economic life.
cnn, bbc, from "human right" point of view, please please let world know the real china inside!!
James, You are very welcome to ASK me about Tibet. But you need to go to china and stay there for a while before you make any comment on Tibet issue.
That `s my opinion base on my back ground and my eyes.. not only from media.
xialin
Hi Valerie.
Thanks for the reply and the food for thought.
My questions...
Did the Communist Party of China invade Tibet in 1950 and subject it to Chinese rule?
Was the the invasion of Tibet by the Communist Party of China illegal, immoral and vile?
Outside of Tibet, did Chairman Mao and the Communist Party of China murder a hundred million Chinese in order to retain power?
By the way, I always refer to the Chinese Communist Party when speaking of the government of China.
Because I don't believe the Chinese people support this government and its crimes at all.
Valerie this isn't BBC or CNN propaganda.
The Communist Party of China did invade Tibet and had no right to do so.
The Communist Party of China's invasion was immoral, illegal and vile.
Chairman Mao and the Communist Party of China did murder a hundred million Chinese between 1950 and 1976.
If you think these things are BBC or CNN propaganda you are attempting to turn truth into lies.
And lies into truth.
Valerie you said 99.9 percent of Chinese agree with their government.
If that was true, wouldn't the Chinese Communist Party allow free elections in the morning?
But it's not true.
And the Chinese Communist Party will never allow free elections.
You said 3000 Chinese protested in Dublin in support of the Chinese Communist Party's policies.
Xiao Lin if even 300 million Chinese protested in support of conquering a peaceful free nation like Tibet, then the action of conquering Tibet would still be illegal, immoral and vile.
If a billion Chinese protested in favour of the above mentioned murder of a nation, the murder would still be murder.
And if the billion were joined by a final 200 million Chinese (bringing the total to 99.9 percent of the population of China) protesting in favour of the Chinese Communist Party's lying mendacious psychotic oppression of an ancient people, why then surely even you must admit that such a protest could still in no way change the lie into truth, could in no way change the mendaciousness into honour, could in no way change the psychosis underlying the oppression into righteous valour, and of course could in no way change any of these things from what they ultimately are, namely sad miserably deluded attempts at concealment of a shabby piratical Chinese Communist Party tyranny.
The truth does not change Xiao Lin just because a billion people love the lie.
But the Communist Party of China has never had even close to a billion people on its side.
If it did, it wouldn't have to commit quite so many mass murders.
Xiao Lin, you made some remarks about the Americans.
I don't agree with what you said about them.
You seem to support the Muslim side in the War On Terror.
You are less supportive of Al Qaeda's actions in the Xinjiang Uighur region of your own country, aren't you?
Funny, that.
America's liberation of Iraq from the Saddam Hussein family murderocracy, and America's liberation of Afghanistan from the hideously deranged Taliban are in no way similar to any trans border actions by the Chinese Communist Party government.
You're on weak ground when you sneer at America.
America's behaviour in the international sphere is on a different moral plain to that of the Chinese Communist Party government.
Take a look at other countries America has liberated.
Western Europe and Eastern Europe, from the Nazis and the Communists.
Italy, German and Japan, from their own dictatorships.
South Korea, Taiwan, and the Philippines, from communist terror movements allied to China.
All those American backed and American protected countries are free.
Not perfect.
But free.
You know what I'm talking about.
You've lived in Ireland.
You've seen freedom.
Whether you wanted to see it or not.
Now look at the countries which have been liberated by the Communist Party of China.
Honestly.
I'm begging you to look at them.
You need never speak to me or write to me again.
But at least for these brief few moments, allow yourself to look on the tiniest infinitesimal possibility that everything you've always believed is utterly crassly wrong.
Look at the countries who are allies of China.
The countries whose governments could not exist without the support of the Communist Party of China.
Burmah.
North Korea.
Zimbabwe.
The Islamic Republic of Sudan.
Xiao Lin... The people of these countries survive under the most evil dictatorships on the planet. You don't have to be religious to know evil when you see it. You don't have to be religious to know that evil can never be good. Nor can evil ever produce good results. No matter how many billions protest that it does. You don't have to be pro American to recognise that the Chinese Communist Party is the only thing propping up the useless clownish dictators in Burmah, North Korea, Zimbabwe, and Sudan. These are unbecoming friends for any Chinese person. They shame you. The murders Xiao Lin. The rapes. The starvation. All because those countries are following a communist path sponsored by your government, a path which leads to nothing but impoverishment, desolation, and death.
China must step from the communist path to the path of life.
You say to me that China is strong.
How can China be strong when the Communist Party of China has stolen Tibet from its own people?
Strong countries are not petty thieves.
How can China be strong when the Communist Party of China doesn't allow the people of China to say what they truly think about anything?
Strong countries are not afraid of words.
And how can you, a daughter of China, say to me that China is strong when the Communist Party of China forces Chinese women to abort their unborn children in their millions every year?
Is this strength?
This is barbarism Xiao Lin.
You and your people will answer to God for it.
There was another interesting comment you made.
You suggested I could not know about China until I had lived there.
This of course answers all my arguments without answering any of them.
It is unworthy of you Xiao Lin.
Remember I'm Irish.
A significant minority of my Irish (generally communist) countrymen spent the past eighty years inflicting terrorism on the rest of us. Whenever they were challenged about this, they would reply: "You don't know what you're talking about because you don't live where we live."
I thought it was a specious argument then from the terrorists.
I think it is a specious argument from you now.
I'm telling you Xiao Lin, I can oppose murder in any country on earth, without living in the same neighbourhood as every murderer on the planet.
I can and I do.
You made some references to the religion of the Tibetans.
But the Tibetans have invaded no country.
Their religion has a lot more in its favour than the atheistic communist twaddle you seem so proud of.
Perhaps the Communist Party of China could take some lessons from the Tibetans on how it should conduct itself towards its neighbours and towards the rest of the world.
Xiao Lin your remarks about the Dalai Lama seemed unfair to me.
The Dalai Lama is a man of peace.
The Chinese Communist Party should treat him with respect.
The Chinese Communist Party should renounce every lie it has ever told about him.
The Chinese Communist Party should make itself accountable to the truth with regard to the Dalai Lama and indeed with regard to everything else.
What a golden age would dawn for mankind in that hour.
Then would the Chinese people truly have stood up.
You know something.
China will be free of this communist dictatorship you so love.
Otherwise Xiao Lin, the God you don't believe in will fling your armies from Tibet in a single night.
Your glittering cities will be brought low by the wrath of the Creator you have denied.
Your ancient culture, your spectacular accomplishments throughout history, your sublime technologies, your nation's illustrious destiny, all will be washed away in a moment like a splash of mud from the path of life.
Honorable and noble Xiao Lin, I tell you this because I love you.
James
PS: CNN and the BBC hate President Bush more than you do.
how are you? i am glad you ask me about tibet. some people even don't do any research but they already made their mind by media.
have you heard cnn apologize for the fake picture and untrue report about tibet at the beginning of riot? of course not, they didn't repeat it as usual. but at least they did once and they took down the picture from internet as request. and in japan anybody who join to march for support tibet against olympic will be paid 100 euro per day, this is my friend who study in tokyo phoned me and told me, by the way there were 3000 chinese people on o'connell st to march for support olympic and chinese government, we informed all the tv channel, but nobody came on that day to report, only irish time took picture then report it in the middle of pages. but there were 3 tibet people with flag standing on street a few monthes ago, their news everywhere. i do understand we need fully respect 3 tibet people's voice, but why ignore our 3000 people's voice and stories? why fake news from cnn?why western media try to block all the support government news?what's going on?
One thing is for sure , we are not American following dog! at least we didn't vote yes on the issue of iraq war just for get bush's happy face! Honestly, we have completely opposite political system from western country. And we are getting stronger and stronger, but does that means we will control the world and cause the war?have you see any that type Chinese? i want to say we are easy going and hard working people. we don't want to cause any trouble, we just want to let our life getting better and better, under this government, our life getting much better, they still have problems, but they are progressing for the country, I grew up in china and stayed in Ireland for 7 years, and come back china once per year, I watch cnn bbc everyday in ireland. my eyes tell me the truth! not cnn or bbc. Tibet is a big tourist place not only for foreigner but also for Chinese, my father was there for holiday and his collegue was working there for 3 years. the people have peaceful and religion life there, government don't want change their life at all, maybe their special life style can attract a lot tourists as well. But the people there have right to choose their own life style, not just following the tradition. So the government build school, restaurants, electricity, tv, shower (because as tradition they only should have 3 showers in their life.). if they want to go to school for education instead of going to temple for all their life, they have right to choose themselves, not dalai lama!! nobody should use religion to control their people, people have right to choose their life and religion! do you think dalai lama would be happy to see his followers getting less and less? Do you think American like us to be stronger? Are they really care about our people's life or they just try to destroy our government to build another new one who can only say yes to American!?why they only report bad news about us?why they wouldn't let word know 99.9% chinese support and happy about our current government? Inside Tibet the people are very angery about the western media un truth reports, they are happy about their life but some people try to use riot monks to make up stories. that's why dalai lama state that he didn't seek independent but freedom, actually he knew nobody will vote for him except his following monks and American! because people are happy there, that's the real truth!
Even if we open the gate of tibet for western media, but they only report a few monks voice and ignore most Tibet people's voice, what should we do?
Can our true voice be heard by world? Can we spread truth bigger than cnn, bbc, wester media community? From this lesson, we know we can't. they are too strong. They can tell whatever they want , truth or fake, it is up to them. we were crying without sound when we see all the world try to against Chinese government which they are making effort to develop our economic life.
cnn, bbc, from "human right" point of view, please please let world know the real china inside!!
James, You are very welcome to ASK me about Tibet. But you need to go to china and stay there for a while before you make any comment on Tibet issue.
That `s my opinion base on my back ground and my eyes.. not only from media.
xialin
Hi Valerie.
Thanks for the reply and the food for thought.
My questions...
Did the Communist Party of China invade Tibet in 1950 and subject it to Chinese rule?
Was the the invasion of Tibet by the Communist Party of China illegal, immoral and vile?
Outside of Tibet, did Chairman Mao and the Communist Party of China murder a hundred million Chinese in order to retain power?
By the way, I always refer to the Chinese Communist Party when speaking of the government of China.
Because I don't believe the Chinese people support this government and its crimes at all.
Valerie this isn't BBC or CNN propaganda.
The Communist Party of China did invade Tibet and had no right to do so.
The Communist Party of China's invasion was immoral, illegal and vile.
Chairman Mao and the Communist Party of China did murder a hundred million Chinese between 1950 and 1976.
If you think these things are BBC or CNN propaganda you are attempting to turn truth into lies.
And lies into truth.
Valerie you said 99.9 percent of Chinese agree with their government.
If that was true, wouldn't the Chinese Communist Party allow free elections in the morning?
But it's not true.
And the Chinese Communist Party will never allow free elections.
You said 3000 Chinese protested in Dublin in support of the Chinese Communist Party's policies.
Xiao Lin if even 300 million Chinese protested in support of conquering a peaceful free nation like Tibet, then the action of conquering Tibet would still be illegal, immoral and vile.
If a billion Chinese protested in favour of the above mentioned murder of a nation, the murder would still be murder.
And if the billion were joined by a final 200 million Chinese (bringing the total to 99.9 percent of the population of China) protesting in favour of the Chinese Communist Party's lying mendacious psychotic oppression of an ancient people, why then surely even you must admit that such a protest could still in no way change the lie into truth, could in no way change the mendaciousness into honour, could in no way change the psychosis underlying the oppression into righteous valour, and of course could in no way change any of these things from what they ultimately are, namely sad miserably deluded attempts at concealment of a shabby piratical Chinese Communist Party tyranny.
The truth does not change Xiao Lin just because a billion people love the lie.
But the Communist Party of China has never had even close to a billion people on its side.
If it did, it wouldn't have to commit quite so many mass murders.
Xiao Lin, you made some remarks about the Americans.
I don't agree with what you said about them.
You seem to support the Muslim side in the War On Terror.
You are less supportive of Al Qaeda's actions in the Xinjiang Uighur region of your own country, aren't you?
Funny, that.
America's liberation of Iraq from the Saddam Hussein family murderocracy, and America's liberation of Afghanistan from the hideously deranged Taliban are in no way similar to any trans border actions by the Chinese Communist Party government.
You're on weak ground when you sneer at America.
America's behaviour in the international sphere is on a different moral plain to that of the Chinese Communist Party government.
Take a look at other countries America has liberated.
Western Europe and Eastern Europe, from the Nazis and the Communists.
Italy, German and Japan, from their own dictatorships.
South Korea, Taiwan, and the Philippines, from communist terror movements allied to China.
All those American backed and American protected countries are free.
Not perfect.
But free.
You know what I'm talking about.
You've lived in Ireland.
You've seen freedom.
Whether you wanted to see it or not.
Now look at the countries which have been liberated by the Communist Party of China.
Honestly.
I'm begging you to look at them.
You need never speak to me or write to me again.
But at least for these brief few moments, allow yourself to look on the tiniest infinitesimal possibility that everything you've always believed is utterly crassly wrong.
Look at the countries who are allies of China.
The countries whose governments could not exist without the support of the Communist Party of China.
Burmah.
North Korea.
Zimbabwe.
The Islamic Republic of Sudan.
Xiao Lin... The people of these countries survive under the most evil dictatorships on the planet. You don't have to be religious to know evil when you see it. You don't have to be religious to know that evil can never be good. Nor can evil ever produce good results. No matter how many billions protest that it does. You don't have to be pro American to recognise that the Chinese Communist Party is the only thing propping up the useless clownish dictators in Burmah, North Korea, Zimbabwe, and Sudan. These are unbecoming friends for any Chinese person. They shame you. The murders Xiao Lin. The rapes. The starvation. All because those countries are following a communist path sponsored by your government, a path which leads to nothing but impoverishment, desolation, and death.
China must step from the communist path to the path of life.
You say to me that China is strong.
How can China be strong when the Communist Party of China has stolen Tibet from its own people?
Strong countries are not petty thieves.
How can China be strong when the Communist Party of China doesn't allow the people of China to say what they truly think about anything?
Strong countries are not afraid of words.
And how can you, a daughter of China, say to me that China is strong when the Communist Party of China forces Chinese women to abort their unborn children in their millions every year?
Is this strength?
This is barbarism Xiao Lin.
You and your people will answer to God for it.
There was another interesting comment you made.
You suggested I could not know about China until I had lived there.
This of course answers all my arguments without answering any of them.
It is unworthy of you Xiao Lin.
Remember I'm Irish.
A significant minority of my Irish (generally communist) countrymen spent the past eighty years inflicting terrorism on the rest of us. Whenever they were challenged about this, they would reply: "You don't know what you're talking about because you don't live where we live."
I thought it was a specious argument then from the terrorists.
I think it is a specious argument from you now.
I'm telling you Xiao Lin, I can oppose murder in any country on earth, without living in the same neighbourhood as every murderer on the planet.
I can and I do.
You made some references to the religion of the Tibetans.
But the Tibetans have invaded no country.
Their religion has a lot more in its favour than the atheistic communist twaddle you seem so proud of.
Perhaps the Communist Party of China could take some lessons from the Tibetans on how it should conduct itself towards its neighbours and towards the rest of the world.
Xiao Lin your remarks about the Dalai Lama seemed unfair to me.
The Dalai Lama is a man of peace.
The Chinese Communist Party should treat him with respect.
The Chinese Communist Party should renounce every lie it has ever told about him.
The Chinese Communist Party should make itself accountable to the truth with regard to the Dalai Lama and indeed with regard to everything else.
What a golden age would dawn for mankind in that hour.
Then would the Chinese people truly have stood up.
You know something.
China will be free of this communist dictatorship you so love.
Otherwise Xiao Lin, the God you don't believe in will fling your armies from Tibet in a single night.
Your glittering cities will be brought low by the wrath of the Creator you have denied.
Your ancient culture, your spectacular accomplishments throughout history, your sublime technologies, your nation's illustrious destiny, all will be washed away in a moment like a splash of mud from the path of life.
Honorable and noble Xiao Lin, I tell you this because I love you.
James
PS: CNN and the BBC hate President Bush more than you do.
posted by heelers | 3:03 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home