the jurisprudence of charles meenan

In  September a High Court Judge styling himself Charles Meenan illegally and criminally ordered the abandonment of a government mandated investigation into the murder of a Syrian woman called Malak Thawley on the operating table at Hollis Street hospital.
The gambit by Charles Meenan subverted the government's power at the behest of the administrator of the hospital, one Doctor Rhona Mahony.
Charles Meenan has further ordered that the State should pay Rhona Mahony and her hospital's costs in securing his court order to cover up their murder of Malak Thawley.
In making this ruling Charles Meenan overruled the elected government of Ireland in the person of Health Minister Simon Harris.
Charles Meenan also disregarded calls from former Justice Minister Alan Shatter for an enquiry.
Charles Meenan, while engaging in hand wringing lacrimose platitudes about his sympathy for Malak Thawley's husband Alan, also chose to ignore Alan Thawley's calls for a full independent enquiry into the circumstances of his wife's death.
Charles Meenan's ruling is an attentat upon separation of powers between State and Judiciary as well as being a usurpation of the democratic will of the people of Ireland.
In making his illegal and criminal ruling Charles Meenan claimed that there had already been three enquiries into Malak Thawley's death.
None of these pseudo enquiries were full independent enquiries.
One purported enquiry was by Rhona Mahony's friends and perhaps by herself, that is to say an internal enquiry at the hospital where Rhona Mahony's staff murdered Malak Thawley.
The second supposed enquiry was by the Health Service Executive, that is to say by yet more of Rhona Mahony's friends and colleagues within the medical service.
The pattycake results of these two non enquiries posing as enquiries, indulge in the usual scapegoating of systems failure and lack of resources as an excuse for Malak Thawley's death.
The third enquiry referred to by Charles Meenan in his court room was the Coroner's Inquest which concluded Malak Thawley had been killed by medical misadventure.
At the Coroner's Inquest, lawyers for Rhona Mahony and her hospital managed to prevent Alan Thawley's lawyers from asking questions about whether or not his wife was murdered.
So even the Coroner's Inquest too was in  its way a non enquiry although its conclusion mandated fully the independent enquiry which was then initiated by Health Minister Simon Harris and which Charles Meenan has now unilaterally quashed on behalf of Rhona Mahony and her murderous staff and her charnel house of a hospital.
According to the Irish Times Charles Meenan justified his court room cover up of the murder of Malak Thawley at Rhona Mahony's hospital by claiming that Health Minister Simon Harris had been "irrational and unreasonable" in ordering an enquiry into "what happened when such practices being investigated exist without intervention at other hospitals."
This is mafia talk by Charles Meenan.
It does not justify murder.
Nor can it.
The claimed failure to hold enquiries in previous cases involving circumstances which Charles Meenan does not specify, must not be allowed to facilitate this mafioso Judge in letting his friends at Hollis Street hospital kill people with impunity.
In Charles Meenan's notion of law, if a single murder takes place without investigation, other murders may not then be investigated.
He does not say what similar practices have taken place in other Irish hospitals.
He could even theoretically be referring to real murders and violations such as those committed by Doctor Michael Neary, Doctor Andrea Herman or Nurse Noreen Mulholland.
In any case it is clearly not in the public interest that the evasion of justice by other perpetrators should be used as a justification by the corrupt Judge Charles Meenan in preventing mandated government enquiries into the murder of Malak Thawley by Rhona Mahony and her staff at Hollis Street hospital.
That is all.